Index Annuities: Earning Market Returns Without the Market Risk

Index annuities, also known as fixed index annuities and equity-index annuities, provide a safe retirement investment option for conservative investors seeking a balance between growth and stability. Index annuities are insurance contracts that have gained popularity as an important tool in retirement planning. They are an excellent choice for investors with moderate risk tolerance, offering the opportunity to earn competitive interest rates while also guaranteeing a stable retirement income.

Index annuities allow investors to earn interest based on the performance of specific market indexes like the S&P 500, Nasdaq 100, among others. They feature account protection against market loss, tax-deferred growth, and the potential for higher returns compared to traditional fixed annuities.

A Deep Dive into What Makes Index Annuities Unique

Index annuities link their interest rate to the performance of an underlying market index like the S&P 500, Nasdaq 100 and others. If the market index performs well, the annuity has the potential to earn a higher rate of return than a traditional fixed annuity. However, even if the market index performs poorly, the annuity still provides a guaranteed minimum rate of return, ensuring that the principal investment and all previously earned interest remain shielded from market downturns. 

Index annuities typically credit interest based on caps or participating rates. This feature offers peace of mind by guaranteeing that you won’t lose money during market downturns.

Caps: A cap is a limit on the amount of interest you can earn in a given time period, typically a month or a year. For instance, if your index annuity has a cap rate of 10% for the year, this means the most you can earn is 10%, even if the underlying index increases by a higher percentage. So, if the index increases by 13% and your cap is 10%, you’ll still only get credited with 10% interest for that period.

Participation Rates: The participation rate in an index annuity is the percentage of the index’s return with which the annuity is credited. For instance, if the participation rate is 80%, and the underlying market index increases by 10% in a given year, the annuity would be credited with an 8% gain (80% of the 10% gain).

However, as illustrated in the following chart, you have the potential to earn similar returns (interest) to the index itself over the long term, because index annuities protect the account value from market downturns. Earning similar interest without having the worry of losing money to the markets provides index annuity account holders with the peace of mind of knowing their money is fully protected from the markets.

While index annuities maintain their full value, investments like IRAs and 401(k)s in the stock market can carry significant risks.

Contact one of our annuity experts at Annuity Emporium to better understand how index annuities typically credit interest, based on caps or participation rates.

Investment Safety and Growth: The Dual Perks of Index Annuities

• Principal Protection: Index annuities offer a safety net for your investment; both your principal and all previously earned interest are protected from market losses.
• Tax-Deferred Growth: Like other annuities, index annuities allow your earnings to grow tax-deferred. This means you won’t pay taxes on your gains until you make withdrawals.
• Higher Return Potential: Index annuities have the potential for higher returns based on market index performance.
• Flexible Withdrawal Options: Index annuities often offer flexible withdrawal options, including lump-sum payments, periodic income payments, and lifetime income options.
• Inheritance Benefits: Index annuities can provide death benefits, allowing you to pass on any remaining funds to your beneficiaries.
• Additional Riders: Many index annuities offer optional Annuity Riders, such as long-term care benefits, inflation protection, and enhanced death benefits.
• Floor Rate: This rate refers to the minimum guaranteed rate of return provided by the annuity, regardless of market index performance.
• Guaranteed Retirement Income for Life: Several insurance companies we work with offer index annuities that guarantee lifetime income you cannot outlive with the potential of that income to increase during your retirement based on the performance of market indexes.

Index vs. Fixed Annuities: Laying Out the Differences

While both index and fixed annuities provide principal protection, tax-deferred growth, ability to guarantee a lifetime income stream and provide the opportunity to add riders, there are some key differences between the two:

• Rates of Return: Fixed annuities guarantee a specific rate of return, while index annuities have the potential for higher returns based on market index performance. Fixed annuities can be compared to Certificates of Deposit (CDs), while index annuities resemble stock mutual funds but with downside protection.
• Risk Levels: Fixed annuities are generally considered lower risk than index annuities, as they offer a guaranteed rate of return regardless of market conditions. Index annuities are considered medium risk. They guarantee your account value will be protected from market downturns; however, the return on those negative market years will be zero interest, but never negative.
• Interest Crediting: Fixed annuities credit interest at a predetermined rate, whereas index annuities credit interest based on the performance of an underlying market index.

Hybrid Annuities: Offering the Best of Both Investment Worlds

As the name suggests, hybrid annuities are a blend of fixed and index annuities. Like fixed annuities, hybrid annuities can provide you with a guaranteed income stream, with the possibility for that income to increase throughout retirement based on the performance of the allocated indices.

• Secure Income Stream: Hybrid annuities, like fixed annuities, can be set up to provide a secure income stream for a set time span, such as 5, 10 or 20 years.
• Guaranteed Lifetime Income: They can also be set up to guarantee a lifetime income stream that you and your spouse cannot outlive.
• Market-Linked Growth: Hybrid annuities offer a rate of return that is tied to a specific market index, such as the S&P 500. If the index performs well, your account is credited with interest corresponding to that performance.
• Principal Protection: Like fixed and index annuities, hybrid annuities are fully protected from market losses and will never experience negative returns.
• Your Guaranteed Retirement Income Can Increase Throughout Retirement: The performance of allocated indices can boost your income level. Importantly, this income is guaranteed to never decrease. Each income increase sets a new guaranteed baseline. This baseline can rise further with strong index performance.
• Peace of Mind: Hybrid annuities give you the peace of mind of knowing what income you are guaranteed to receive throughout your retirement, and that income has the potential to increase—but never decrease—to keep up with inflation.

Maximizing Retirement: Why Roll Over Your 401(k) or IRA to Index Annuities?

As you approach and transition into retirement, do you wish for the added stress and worry of stock market ups and downs? Can you handle a 20, 30 or 40 percent loss in your retirement savings? What if it happened again in three, five or ten years? Since WWII, the average stock market correction (defined as 20% or more market loss) took place on average every 3.5 years. As the “Power of Protection” chart above showed, some of those corrections can be large and last for many years.

Index annuities and 401(k) or IRA mutual funds both offer the potential for growth based on market performance. However, there are some notable differences between the two retirement options:

• Protection Against Losses: A standout feature of index annuities is the guaranteed minimum return, which protects you from market losses. Index annuities are tied to market indexes, such as the S&P 500, Nasdaq 100 and others. You are credited an interest when the index goes up. However, if the index declines, your account value remains fully protected from market downturns. This is especially important as we age since we have less time to make up for market losses, and are less capable of dealing with the stress associated with market volatility and downturns.
• Tax Deferral: The earnings from your index annuity are tax-deferred just like in a 401(k) or IRA. You can roll over your existing 401(k) or IRA to an annuity. In addition, you can roll over your CDs, mutual funds, and other retirement-designated savings into an index annuity to benefit from tax-deferred growth. Unlike, 401(k)s and IRAs, there are no IRS maximum contribution limits to annuities.
• Guaranteed Income for Life: Index annuities can guarantee a lifetime income stream you cannot outlive. IRAs and 401(k)s cannot do that.
• Flexibility and Control: Depending on your contract specifics, you may be able to customize your annuity with various options and riders, such as a death benefit for your heirs (typically a free option), long-term care insurance (typically at a cost), or protection against inflation.
• No contribution limits: Unlike 401(k)s and IRAs, there is no limit to how much money you can invest in an annuity.

Optimizing Returns: From CDs/Mutual Funds to Index Annuities

Certificates of deposit (CDs) and index annuities are both considered relatively safe investment options, and stock index mutual funds are considered high risk. If your CDs and mutual funds are designated for retirement, there are many benefits of rolling them over into an index annuity:

• Return Potential: Index annuities typically offer higher returns or interest compared to CDs, and similar to mutual funds due to their link to market index performance (“Power of Protection” chart above).
• Account Protection: Unlike mutual funds, index annuities provide protection from market downturns. If the index to which the annuity is linked decreases in value, the annuity account value will not decrease. The original investment, as well as all interests earned in prior periods, are protected from market downturns.
• Guaranteed Minimum Returns: Unlike stock mutual funds, index annuities are protected from market losses. This can be particularly beneficial for individuals nearing retirement who want to reduce their risk exposure.
• Tax-deferred Growth: Like 401(k)s and IRAs, the growth in index annuities is also tax-deferred. This means that, unlike CDs and mutual funds, you don’t pay taxes on the gains until you begin to take withdrawals. Tax deferral allows your savings to grow faster providing you with a larger income during retirement.
• Liquidity: CDs generally have shorter investment terms and lower penalties for early withdrawal compared to index annuities. However, most index annuities generally allow penalty-free withdrawals up to 10% of the account value each year. The penalties, or surrender charges, in an index annuity go down over time and eventually completely go away. With CDs the penalties remain each time you roll them over.
• Lifetime Income Stream: Annuities can provide a lifetime income stream, which can be a significant benefit for retirees who worry about outliving their savings.

Boost Your Pension Benefits with Index Annuities

Pension plans typically use fixed interest annuities as the investment vehicle. There are many benefits to rolling over your pension plan to a fixed or an index annuity that we offer. They include the potential for higher guaranteed monthly income, death benefit to your beneficiaries as opposed to the pension plan keeping your money when you pass away, or adding riders such as long-term care and inflation protection. 

• Potential for Growth: Index annuities are linked to a specific market index (like the S&P 500). Pension plans use fixed annuities that have a set interest rate. Index annuities have the potential to earn higher interest rates than fixed annuities, providing for a higher income during retirement.
• Protection from Market Losses: Index annuities have a floor, meaning your account value is protected from market losses. This provides you peace of mind and stability compared to direct investment in the stock market, while giving you the potential to earn higher interests than your pension plan.
• Customization: Many annuities offer a variety of optional riders that can customize the annuity to your needs. These could include enhanced death benefits, long-term care benefits, and income benefits.
• Flexibility & Accessibility: When you annuitize your pension, you relinquish all control over the funds to the pension provider. They will guarantee you an income stream, typically for life, but you won’t be able to take out additional funds for emergencies or other needs. There are some index annuities that we offer which guarantee a lifetime income stream, but allow for flexibility of taking out additional funds when needed.
• Death Benefit: Pension annuities typically restrict payouts to the pensioner and, at most, their spouse. If both pass away early, the pension company gets to keep your remaining money. The index annuities we offer often have death benefits. This means that any money left over after you pass away goes to your beneficiary and not the pension company.

Start Your Journey to a Secure Retirement with Trusted Solutions from Annuity Emporium

Why settle for just one or two options when you can choose from dozens of the best? At Annuity Emporium, we aren’t restricted to a single insurance company. We offer you a carefully-chosen range of highly-rated fixed, index, and hybrid annuities from industry-leading providers—each tailored to meet your unique retirement goals.

Get Your FREE Customized Annuity Illustration Today!

Curious about which type of annuity—fixed, index, or hybrid—is ideal for you? Take the guesswork out of retirement planning with our complimentary, personalized annuity illustrations. Learn how you can secure a lifetime retirement income that is both guaranteed and has the potential to grow, but will never decrease.

Ready to Talk?

Connect with our experienced annuity specialists today at 866-321-2347, or complete the form to schedule your no-obligation consultation.